After what feels like an eternity, Borderlands 4 has finally been revealed, but only through a cryptic teaser trailer. The teaser doesn’t reveal much outright, except for some Eridian writing and a mysterious face at the end that’s already sparked plenty of fan theories. Some initially speculated it might be Borderlands 2's iconic villain Handsome Jack making a return, but Gearbox CEO Randy Pitchford quickly shut that down. He stated that the face wasn’t Jack, but rather "something far more dangerous and sinister."
This revelation leaves a lot to the imagination. While Handsome Jack left massive shoes for any villain to fill, the notion of a threat "far more dangerous and sinister" is intriguing. Could this darker figure bring back the level of menace that the series so desperately needs?
The Problem with Borderlands 3's Villains
Let’s be honest — Borderlands 3’s villains, the Calypso Twins, didn't quite live up to the series' high expectations. Sure, they had their moments of charm, but they were more annoying than intimidating. Their personas, heavily inspired by modern-day social media influencers, brought a comedic element that went too far, making them feel less threatening and more like a parody. While the Borderlands franchise has always had a flair for the absurd, it works best when balanced with genuine menace. Unfortunately, the Twins lacked that balance. Instead of being a force to be reckoned with, they became caricatures.
Many fans agree that the Calypso Twins were trying too hard to replicate Handsome Jack’s unique blend of charisma, cruelty, and intelligence. But that approach backfired because they never managed to capture the menace that Jack naturally exuded. Jack was someone you feared, respected, and even grudgingly liked — the Calypso Twins were just... there.
Why Borderlands 4's Darker Villain is Promising
So, what makes Borderlands 4’s new antagonist so promising? Simply put, the franchise needs a villain that breaks away from the failed attempts of the past. A return to a darker, more menacing figure could be exactly what Borderlands needs to restore its sense of danger and intensity.
If the teaser’s Eridian writing is any indication, we might be diving deeper into the mysterious alien lore that has been part of the Borderlands universe for years. There's also speculation that The Watcher — a character first introduced in Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel — could play a major role in this new chapter. Given the enigmatic and ominous nature of the Eridians, this shift towards a more serious and sinister villain could inject fresh life into the narrative.
What Borderlands 4 needs to avoid is making the mistake of trying to recreate Handsome Jack in any form. As beloved as he is, attempts to mimic him (like the Calypso Twins) only highlight the shortcomings of those characters. Instead, the new villain needs to be their own unique entity, bringing a new level of danger, mystery, and perhaps even a deeper connection to the universe’s lore.
Going Darker Might Be Exactly What Borderlands Needs
Borderlands is at its best when it blends chaotic humor with high stakes. The villains need to feel like a genuine threat — someone who pushes the Vault Hunters to their limits, both physically and emotionally. A darker tone doesn't mean abandoning the series' trademark humor, but it does mean grounding it in a villain who is genuinely dangerous.
The teaser trailer has certainly left fans wanting more, and that’s a good thing. By hinting at something “far more dangerous and sinister,” Borderlands 4 may finally bring a villain who not only lives up to the legacy of Handsome Jack but surpasses it. With the potential involvement of the Eridians and deeper exploration of the franchise's lore, Borderlands 4 could be the darkest, most intense entry yet.
Gearbox has set the stage for something massive, and if they deliver, it could be a game-changer for the series.
Comment Section
Latest
